Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Neil Carlson's avatar

I’m confused. I’m still unsure what I’m supposed to repent of. I’m not same-sex attracted. I’ve committed no sins in your eyes. I don’t want to leave because you drew a moral line. I want to leave because you drew an immoral, un-Christlike line that in practice refuses to accept any innocent-until-proven-guilty do-unto-others logic.

I want to show a lot more mercy than you do. That is all. Is that a sin? Am I indeed in rebellion against God’s duly appointed authority, is that my error? I still respect the just hammer of church discipline when it is brought down on self-indulgent, arrogant, greedy, licentious, exploitative, bigoted people of any ilk or perspective. What am I supposed to repent of to allow me to stay? Of my up-close-and-personal experience that you all treat church order like a weapon to be wielded instead of a shield for the innocent and the vulnerable and the repentant and the forgiven?

I am and have been increasingly repentant of having once reveled in the exercise of power and privilege in the name of Jesus. Humility calls me to leave. It would cause me to fall back into prideful sin to stay.

Expand full comment
John Showalter's avatar

I am most thankful for the compassion expressed by the author of this article for his Church, the CRC. If the CRC were to continue in unmooring itself from its biblical foundations in order to make peace with the world, it would simply join the lot of mainline churches that have preceded it in that direction. Thus, becoming indistinct from the world, and therefore serving no purpose other than to parrot, “me too!”

Instead, the author seeks to extend a hand of understanding and fellowship to those who call themselves affirming. I take him at his word, that he wishes to see the church fully restored. But true restoration comes only when Scripture is at its heart.

We must meet in Christ and on His terms, not our own.

Expand full comment
23 more comments...

No posts